Finally, as an adolescent, my parents told me to just stop talking to them about religion.
This request came up several times for a couple reasons.
My psycho-Christian phase inspired the first request. I found my long-lost uncle during the year I attended Trinity Lutheran private school (shudder) and he introduced me to his church. What began as my desire to be closer to him became a trap for a teenager who took everything so very seriously. If I attended the church, I was going to listen up, sing in the choir, and buy into the magic... there was little that seemed real there. I entered into the organization during a "revival". I still don't know what it's
supposed to mean to the devout members of the Assembly of Gd. People were "rededicating their lives to Christ," getting baptized again, "falling out in the Spirit,"... quite a bit of "hocus pocus" (C'mon... any medievalists in the house?).
I was pretty dazzled at first. Raised in the very quiet and always intellectual Lutheran church of my family, I never imagined such activities going on in a sanctuary. The music was lively, people shouted, testimonials abounded with "miracles of the Lord"... during a "louder" portion of my development, it began appealing enough for me to want to get into the action.
I tried talking to my family about "being saved," which naturally offended them. They were "Christian" after all and believed all the same basic things about Jesus and the crosses and rocks and what have you. Why should it matter what church they attended or whether they bothered other people about what they
should believe?
Still, I was too young to believe I could be wrong.
It wasn't until the church pulled my logic trigger that my zealous behavior died. During a rather rambunctious service, a woman who had been in a wheelchair for as long as I had been attending got up, stood on her legs, and ran in circles around the temple. Shocked and amazed, we all listened to her testimony of how good the Lord was to her... what a miracle He had bestowed on her broken body.
The next Sunday, she was right back in that wheelchair.
No one said anything.
When I tried to ask people about what this meant, I was shrugged off with the typical "Gd's will" sort of excuses. I asked why this Gd they claimed gave her such a gift would take it away? Why give it to her for a few hours and slap her back down? I didn't know her condition, but what was the point of that spectacle? Had she offended Gd somehow? Had no one heard of adrenaline?
Needless to say, that killed my assurance in any sort of faith for a long time.
Which led to the second request... while unable to completely commit atheism (Old habits kill
you first), I started going down the path of the eternal scientist seeking proof for Gd's existence. What was the point? Who has met with Him and brought the news back since Moses? Who were these bearded authors of the Holy Book anyway? My parents, having long accepted the unanswerable quality of their faith had to politely ask again that I refrain from discussing my opinions with them.
While I was oppressive in my youth to people who I thought would listen, we're mostly all asked or advised not to discuss religion at the dinner table or with people we've just met or on first dates. It's a hot button topic. It's so very easy to offend people. Even those who say they embrace all faiths (i.e. Unitarian Universalists) have been known to get heated with people who don't share their openness. Are we condemned as a people to find ourselves unable to talk to one another about what we, quite possibly, treasure the most? Among the most intimate things we possess are beliefs, fears, and values...
...and like other "intimates," maybe they're not meant to be shared with everyone. Maybe the quality of religion is like a relationship... people make a commitment as a group to agree to a creed, a hymn, a gd, an idea. Maybe a certain monogamous love looms over the possibilities of mingling.
And yet, I for one enjoy new ideas or learning older ones. I am no longer committed to any particular religion and prefer to adopt whatever makes sense from whatever information and inspiration I come across... I don't care to lose out on opportunities to learn about these intimate spaces between people, how they came about, and what keeps them faithful.
This is probably due to two people in my life... one who gave me a tolerable version of Gd in which I was more willing to believe... and the other lived the truth I so desperately wanted to see in the world. Perhaps I'll talk about them sometime...
I am distinctly "un-faithful" when it comes to religion. I have trouble believing in anything because I'm too tied in to the idea of Ultimate Truth. A part of me trusts that there is at least one right answer to what governs existence... and I don't take well to picking the wrong answer. So, whatever nothing and everything might
be the Ultimate Truth, I have yet to find it with peace in any specific faith.
Therefor, in the meantime, I'll search, go back to a quiet Lutheran church now and again to ask my questions without condemnation, visit the Buddhist Temple, perform Jewish rituals at home (at least during the holidays), practice my yoga (all branches of my yoga), and listen to others.
I'm happy to say it's a little easier to talk to my parents about religion. Having studied quite a bit of it in college (which largely softened my tendency towards atheism) and done some heavy reading, my parents like to hear the information. They're still content with their religion and even less content with mine than when I was psychotic... but the dialogue is re-opened, acceptance has brought us to a level ground, and we're learning what we can from one another.
Just like I like it.