I decided to hope for the best and brace myself for the worst.
It's only taken me 28 years to finally attend a midnight showing of a freshly released film, so, I tried to celebrate the occasion. I put on my silly white and black striped tights, my little black bow choker, a black skirt with a red top, and black high heels and walked out the door with my also appropriately clad pal, Beth. Aside from just being excited to see each other (which is a rare treat), we were both ready for a midnight premiere...
...though, apparently, the rest of the town was not. You could have joined us without buying your ticket in advance. There was a modest number of people in the theater... all of them seemed to be college students looking for an excuse to get large pitchers of beer.
The scene being set, what can I say for Tim Burton's
ALICE?
(from www.nerdles.com)
Firstly, it was not as bad as I thought it was going to be. If any of you read my very LONG tirade about my concerns for this movie last year, you mostly know what I mean. I wanted to be prepared for the worst, so I read the critics' take on the movie this morning. The reviews were mixed, and I can certainly see why. There's actually a lot to like about this movie... there's also some gruesome stuff that might make you wonder what the hell Disney was thinking.
On to the players: Mia Wisakowska made a fine Alice. Seriously. Most girls playing Alice are stuck in a position of just reacting to the world around them. Wisakowska does that with just enough of the maturity she has achieved with age and a hint of the wild child that we all would like to think resided in all little girls before the world told us what to think of ourselves. She has a weird load to carry... she has to be the grown up version of a person who can't remember anything about a place to which she's already been... With that backdrop, I'd say this girl handled the part well enough. I really can't complain.
The critics love Helena Bonham Carter as the Red Queen. The part itself holds a little contention for me seeing as how the role is really a morph between the Queen of Hearts of
ALICE IN WONDERLAND and the actual Red Queen from
THROUGH THE LOOKING GLASS. What Carter really seemed to try to capture was The Queen of Hearts. She was shrill, rude, immature, and pitched plenty of amusing, spoiled-kid temper tantrums. While I have always liked whatever this actress does, I guess I don't see about what it was that so dazzled the critics about this specific performance. Again, she was good... the only better Queen of Hearts I've seen was the irreplaceable Miranda Richardson. But the other players did some great work as well...
All the minor characters were terrific (particularly Alan Rickman as the voice of The Caterpillar... he was
perfect). The whole cost of a 3-D ticket is worth it just to meet Burton's March Hare, the maddest of the bunch. You know how people tend to mimic funny things from movies long after the movie has ended? I think the March Hare is going to end up in my day-to-day funnies for a while. The only minor character I found truly out of place was the Dormouse... he was not the lovable narcoleptic of the Carroll text. He was some sort of
Tale of Despereaux creation. I just found that elaboration disappointing.
Now, the two real big ticket characters... I'll start with Johnny Depp (only because I know some of you are waiting for me to badmouth Anne Hathaway). The Mad Hatter was definitely fleshed out for this movie. If you read the books, Hatter is just another character Alice meets along the way (though he does appear in both books, not just
WONDERLAND). Though, I've noticed most filmmakers like to linger on the Hatter longer than Carroll offered them text with which to play. Whatever it is about the Hatter that makes everyone want to get to know him better, I am not at all disappointed with Depp's portrayal. I'm getting tired of everyone pulling out the Willie Wonka card on his performance- I think his Hatter is a completely different sort of insane. He's a lot kinder in this movie than he is in the books, or most other movies, but it doesn't distract from what I think most people associate with Hatter... the
fantastic madness. He changes his accent, he follows a train of thought rapidly, he needs to occasionally be snapped out of an angry rant... I don't know... it reminds me a little of Robin Williams' Batty from
Fern Gully. He's crazy, but you want to make him small and keep him in your pocket.
Anne Hathaway...
Well, honestly, I think if we didn't know her from
Princess Diaries or
Prada, or if we didn't have to see her try to be serious in
Rachel Getting Married, I doubt the critics would have disliked her so much. She's not stellar, but she's not wretched either. You kind of can't take your eyes off of her... not because of her acting, but, because of Burton's weird "blond hair on a brunette thing" he has going on. The contrast of her blinding blond hair and her dark eyes, eyebrows, lipstick, and nail polish... it's sort of mesmerizing. As for the portrayal of The White Queen... there was no way for Hathaway to win. After all, The White Queen from the book is a clumsy old bat. Hathaway had to reinvent this character for this sequel... and I'm willing to say that she attempted to maintain the original White Queen's kookiness by giving herself a little tick. She has this serious, ethereal quality and then, suddenly, she'll wrinkle her nose at a bad smell, or swat at a bug, etc. While she was not specifically impressive, I didn't find her terribly unimpressive either.
On to the story...
Like any movies that attempt to follow the book, it's a "coming of age" story. Alice is just 13 years older and trying not to lose the "mad," or more precious parts of her Self. Even better than some productions of
ALICE, I don't feel as though Burton's directing or Linda Woolverton's script spelled anything out for you... they expected the audience to be able to follow what they were trying to say about growing up, constantly fighting to defend yourself, who you are, and not falling into traps people set for you concerning what should be "expected" of a person. I think the film is gently empowering and not emotionally overdone.
There were some gorgeous details in the movie to enjoy. Alice's size issues cause her... wardrobe problems. She has to fashion herself some clothes out of whatever materials are handy. She has some great costumes. Hatter also has a chance to put his trade to use and we look at some pretty fabulous hats. The reviews tell you the truth- there's some great (and terrifying) eye candy... from the monsters and fights to the heart shaped everything in the Red Queen's castle (heart shaped platforms, axes, heads, you name it...) to the insects. Yes, we run into a little bit of corporate production issues (like the horrid end-of-film pop song that goes with all Disney movies to sell cds), but, Burton was born to mix his incomparable imagination with Carroll's zany Wonderland.
Something I think the critics overlooked, since I'm willing to bet few of them have read
ALICE recently, is that there are a handful of nods to the Carroll story within the film. Aside from the characters chosen for the film, lines are taken from the book and not explained. I truly think having read it helps to make sense out of some of the "madness". If the current generation of young people have never read
The Jabberwocky, some of the Hatter's lines are going to sound like gibberish. Some of the monsters will make more sense with having read the stories and poems, too. The best example of the respect for the source text is the running line throughout the film... "I've often believed in as many as 6 impossible things before breakfast." This line derives from a conversation Alice has with the White Queen in
THROUGH THE LOOKING GLASS. For someone who loves the books, I had a few glittering moments in the viewing experience of things I remember from the reading. Is it exact interpretation? No. But they borrowed good stuff from the source text to create a decent sequel.
Sequel. That's the word you must use to accept this project. It is, I am willing to say, a successful sequel to the original stories. Alice has grown up... we've had a chance to follow her development and still love her, to still feel like maybe even we, as the old farts we're destined to be, can maintain a childlike wonder within us that will forever preserve our... to borrow from the new Hatter... "muchness."
(from http://media.onsugar.com/files)